The Denver Broncos had almost 100 more yards of total offense than the Tennessee Titans; they had more first downs, too, and Trevor Siemian‘s passer rating (93.1) doubled up Marcus Mariota‘s (45.4).
But when the clock struck zero, Denver’s offense only totaled 10 points, while Tennessee sat at 13.
So where does the blame fall?
On stats alone, Siemian looked to have a fantastic day, completing 69 percent of his passes for 334 yards and a touchdown, but the stats might not tell the story.
If anything, Siemian’s standout performance took awhile to get going, and that may have cost the Broncos in the long run.
For the first two quarters of the game, the Denver offense couldn’t do anything, as they failed to generate a single point, produced two three-and-outs, punted four times and fumbled away another drive.
The Broncos and their fans were hoping to see the Trevor Siemian that had starred in the second half of the Kansas City Chiefs game, especially after rookie Paxton Lynch produced an anemic performance last week, but that’s not what they got; they got the same quarterback that has helped give this Broncos team the most three-and-outs in the NFL this season.
Most of the time I say this jokingly, but I'm saying this semi-seriously…
Does Peyton Manning feel like playing two months of football?
— Will Petersen (@PetersenWill) December 11, 2016
Paxton Lynch was the problem with this Broncos offense? Are you sure?
— Mark Kiszla (@markkiszla) December 11, 2016
Man, I can't believe Paxton derailed this juggernaut last week. Glad he's finally on the bench where he belongs! #Broncos
— James Merilatt (@jamesmerilatt) December 11, 2016
Meanwhile, "Best Chance to Win" has put up 0 points today. Thank goodness he's back! #Broncos #Siemian
— James Merilatt (@jamesmerilatt) December 11, 2016
In the second half, the Broncos finally started to get things going.
Halfway through the third quarter, Siemian received the ball at his own 27-yard line and promptly drove the offense down the field. He completed four passes for 62 yards, including a crucial 16-yard pass on third-and-15, to get Denver inside the 5.
On third-and-goal from the 4, Siemian had Demaryius Thomas breaking free to the corner of the end zone, but Siemian waited too long to unload the ball, and it fell incomplete.
https://twitter.com/RonnieKRadio/status/808043090455957504
Awful throw into the endzone. #broncos #siemian
— James Merilatt (@jamesmerilatt) December 11, 2016
Gary Kubiak decided to go for it on fourth down, but Siemian’s pass again fell incomplete, 13-0 Titans.
Still getting blanked. #siemian #broncos
— James Merilatt (@jamesmerilatt) December 11, 2016
There was a silver lining, though.
The 13-play, six-minute drive finally gave the defense some time to rest, and they locked in, forcing three consecutive three-and-outs at one point in the second half and holding the Titans offense to zero points.
With 12:34 left in the fourth, Siemian received the ball again, and they drove right down the field for their first score of the game, a 3-yard touchdown pass to Emmanuel Sanders.
On that play, the @titans brought 7 rushers and Siemian a nice play getting rid of it, to @ESanders_10 for TD. #broncos
— Les Shapiro (@LesShapiro) December 11, 2016
On the Broncos very next drive, Siemian again drove right down the field, and on a second-and-goal from the 16-yard line, he rocketed a pass to Bennie Fowler on the goal line, but Fowler dropped the ball, forcing Denver to kick the field goal.
Siemian did what he needed to do. Fowler dropped it
— Michael Jaycox (@MilkyMike) December 11, 2016
https://twitter.com/RonnieKRadio/status/808050190716379137
Great throw from Siemian, bad hands from Fowler.
— Josh Dover (@JoshuaDover) December 11, 2016
Trevor Siemian delivers go-ahead touchdown pass….and Bennie Fowler drops it
— Ed Werder (@WerderEdESPN) December 11, 2016
Should have been caught. Laser
— Vic Lombardi (@VicLombardi) December 11, 2016
Bennie Fowler. Gotta catch that ball. #broncos
— James Merilatt (@jamesmerilatt) December 11, 2016
Trevor Siemian was superb on that drive. Should have been six. Didn't like the run play. Forget the run. Won't work today.
— Vic Lombardi (@VicLombardi) December 11, 2016
Thanks to another stop from the Denver defense, Siemian and the offense would get one more chance to tie up the game, receiving the ball on their own 2-yard line with 2:26 to go.
Six plays later, tight end A.J. Derby would fumble the ball at Denver’s 40-yard line, officially handing the game over to the Titans and putting the Broncos’ playoff hopes in jeopardy.
The question, though, is: Who do we blame?
Not Trevor Siemian, according to many.
Amazed so many on Twitter still killing #Broncos Siemian. No running game–passed for nearly 300 yards & completion % is 67%, TD, No INT
— Eric Goodman (@EricGoodman) December 11, 2016
Win or loss, Trevor Siemian deserves a lot of praise for today. Bad OL, no running game, injured foot and 4 yards shy of 300-yard day.
— Cameron Wolfe (@CameronWolfe) December 11, 2016
https://twitter.com/RonnieKRadio/status/808052018308927488
Don’t forget … Siemian DID throw the game-winning TD. Bennie just dropped it.
— Michael Jaycox (@MilkyMike) December 11, 2016
Trevor Siemian is your quarterback. Dude played a hell of a game.
— Vic Lombardi (@VicLombardi) December 11, 2016
Still, it’s hard to say a quarterback was effective when his offense scores 10 points all game and goes 3-11 on third downs.
Everyone will blame Derby. But you can't score 10 points and win in the NFL. #Broncos #Siemian
— James Merilatt (@jamesmerilatt) December 11, 2016
I don't care if a QB completes a lot of passes underneath and between the 20s. It's about scoring points. The Broncos had 10 today. Ten!
— James Merilatt (@jamesmerilatt) December 11, 2016
https://twitter.com/AllbrightNFL/status/808060540518068225
With the loss, the Broncos’ playoff hopes aren’t dead, but they’re certainly on life support. Facing off against the Chiefs, Patriots and Raiders in the final three weeks will be no easy task.
If Siemian truly wants to prove that he’s the quarterback of the future, he’ll have the opportunity. But he’ll need to play well for all 12 quarters, not four or five.