The Denver Broncos could stand to add some talent to their defensive line, as depth concerns still persist behind Dre’Mont Jones and D.J. Jones.
With that need in mind, who could they target in the draft to revitalize the position group? Let’s take a look at three potential options.
John Ridgeway, Arkansas
If the Broncos decide they want to continue to upgrade their ability to defend the run, which was a major defensive weakness in 2022 (Denver ranked 21st in run defense DVOA a season ago), John Ridgeway would be an ideal target in the mid-to-late rounds.
@RazorbackFB DL John Ridgeway is nicknamed “The Vanilla Gorilla” and I can not think of a more apt name #SeniorBowl pic.twitter.com/ZEyhC9ChBN
— Mike Spencer Hrynyshyn (@MikeHrynyshyn) February 2, 2022
Ridgeway has a mammoth frame, standing just over 6-foot-5 (placing him in the 95th percentile for defensive tackles) and weighing in at 321 pounds (89th percentile), which helps him perform as an upper-echelon run defender.
Although his athleticism won’t wow you, Ridgeway is exceptionally strong, allowing him to anchor with ease, even against SEC double teams. He devours double teams all game long for the Razorbacks’ defense, and he has the durability and stamina to hold those blocks in the fourth quarter just as effectively as he held them in the first quarter.
Here, he even eats up a triple team.
https://twitter.com/mattalkire/status/1501959631563862026?s=21&t=3s3YexDDogXbfKSdTXXFjQ
He’s also able to strike with power, knocking linemen back, and he’s able to toss defenders out of the way when he wants to shed them to make the play in the backfield.
🚨SLEEPER ALERT🚨
Former HS wrestling champ & Illinois State NT John Ridgeway is an impact transfer for @RazorbackFB. Here’s a textbook grown-man rep with sudden lockout & easy block sling. @seniorbowl staff will see @ridgeway_79 (6051v, 320v, 34” arms) play live this week. 💤📈 pic.twitter.com/3qUmqTb3us— Jim Nagy (@JimNagy_SB) September 22, 2021
Ridgeway is a fast processor with excellent eyes and refined hands, making him a bear in the run game when paired with his physical gifts.
The big issues with Ridgeway are that he has very limited mobility and there isn’t a ton of room left for development in his game. He won’t impact the passing game much, and it’s unlikely he ever does. He’s a technician with his hands, and his ability to explode into his blocks allows him to push the pocket some, but he’ll be more of a Mike Purcell upgrade than anything.
John Ridgeway (DL, Arkansas) vs Cade Mays (OL, Tennessee)
Mays widened his hands way too much and Ridgeway, with good pad level, was able to get into his chest, win leverage and drive him back.#SeniorBowl pic.twitter.com/bgIw13BbR7
— Austin Silvey (@reelsilvey) February 3, 2022
That said, he could be an extremely appealing option as a Purcell upgrade.
Phidarian Mathis, Alabama
A more premium option Denver could target to upgrade their defensive line would be Phidarian Mathis of the Crimson Tide.
Mathis boasts a lot of the same strengths as Ridgeway, with his incredible power, excellent vision, clearly apparent football intelligence, polished hand technique, and a motor that never runs cool, but he also offers more versatility and pass-rush potential.
Finished up #Alabama DT Phidarian Mathis’ report up tonight and I’m blown away by the violent hand usage. Swipes the hands uses his lower half power to defeat blocks.
Had a field day against #TAMU. Absolutely a one gap shooter who will thrive on run downs. pic.twitter.com/7n35WzxcKI
— Devin Jackson (@RealD_Jackson) January 15, 2022
He might not quite have the two-gapping ability of Ridgeway, but he’s still a high-end run defender and he has better lateral range along the line of scrimmage. He’ll make tackles from the backside of the play and hang with running backs that are trying to get slippery in the backfield.
https://twitter.com/ajdraftscout/status/1476768979322642432?s=21&t=3s3YexDDogXbfKSdTXXFjQ
Mathis packs a powerful punch that knocks back offensive linemen, and he pairs it with an impressive array of hand moves. He’s demonstrated effective usage of the swipe, chop and rip moves, as well as just his natural talents, to shed blockers and create backfield penetration.
Overall though, his lateral range — despite being superior to Ridgeway — is still lacking, and he also received a lot more help from his supporting cast than most defensive prospects, thanks to playing at Alabama.
Matthew Butler, IDL, Tennessee
If the Broncos want a different flavor of defensive tackle, they could look to add Tennessee’s Matthew Butler, who has much better movement skills but lacks the strength of the two options above.
Butler is able to smoothly scrape across the offensive line to make plays outside his gap and on the backside of runs pretty frequently. He’s also able to slip through tight creases in the offensive line and use his solid get-off to shoot gaps and blow up plays in the backfield.
Tennessee DT Matthew Butler is a little-known prospect but is still intriguing nonetheless.
Here he shows a great first step matched with even better use of the rip move to leverage a sack here in the 1st quarter. pic.twitter.com/6qfgmTlHkr
— Nick Price (checkmark) (@PriceCheck3) November 15, 2021
His movement skills also show up on twists and stunts, where he thrives and is consistently a productive pass rusher.
He’s also technically refined, with fast hands that constantly remain busy through the rep and make him a headache for opposing linemen, and he has excellent instincts and reactionary ability.
https://twitter.com/mattalkire/status/1488275699421130754?s=21&t=3s3YexDDogXbfKSdTXXFjQ
Butler’s on-field work ethic and activity level should also excite Broncos Country.
However, his lighter frame and limited strength could lead to him getting bullied at the NFL level. His run defense relies pretty heavily on creating backfield penetration, rather than anchoring and shedding defenders, and he might struggle to translate that ability to create penetration to the NFL, considering his athletic limitations.
Butler’s 33-inch arms aren’t too terribly short, but he struggles to utilize that length, so they appear to be much shorter when studying him on tape.
Although he’s certainly an intriguing player, Butler would feel a little redundant given the Broncos presently existing depth options on the roster. He could serve as an insurance policy for Dre’Mont Jones’ impending free agency, though, it goes without saying that he’s nowhere near Jones’ talent level.