When Broncos running back Jamaal Charles coughed up the football on his third touch of the night in his return to Arrowhead Stadium, social media critics expected the former Chief would have the worst night of anyone dressed in orange and blue. By the time quarterback Trevor Siemian had thrown his second interception of the game, he had easily trumped Charles for that claim. By Siemian’s third interception (Denver’s fifth turnover of the game), head coach Vance Joseph had assumed the mantle.
It was a terrible night for Charles, whose fumble led to a Marcus Peters scoop-and-score and an early Chiefs lead. Even Charles’ 39 yards on eight carries, which put him over 10,000 yards from scrimmage for his career, were no real salve after giving up that opening score.
It was a worse night for Siemian, who completed just 4 of 15 passes in the first half and was intercepted twice. His passer rating at halftime was a measly 8.9. (158.3 is considered perfect.) He ended the game 19-for-36 with a touchdown and three interceptions. Siemian was sacked three times for 11 yards in the loss.
Beyond the box score, Siemian made multiple poor throws – under- and overthrowing receivers – and multiple poor decisions that led to the lopsided outcome. (Denver lost 29-19, but trailed 20-3 early in the second half.) He had thrown an interception before he had completed a pass. His second interception came when he tried to float a ball deep to Jordan Taylor when it appeared he could have run for a first down, instead (and on third down, no less). Siemian’s performance solicited numerous calls for him to be benched at halftime.
The only person who bore more criticism than Siemian was Joseph, who stuck with the quarterback despite Siemian’s ineffectiveness. Joseph also made several other questionable calls that had just as many folks calling for his job, or at least questioning his competence as a head coach, as there were wanting to see Siemian benched.
After Isaiah McKenzie fumbled a punt that cost Denver its first offensive possession of the second half (his fourth fumble of the year), Joseph trotted the rookie out again on the next punt play. That caught the ire of many observers, as did Joseph’s decision to go for it on fourth down in the fourth quarter.
With just over 10:00 to play and the Broncos trailing by 10 with the ball at their own 48. Denver did not convert the play and Kansas City converted another field goal (one of four in the half) to extend their lead.
It was an avalanche of frustration from onlookers that will surely have Broncos Country talking deep into next week about the future at quarterback and the future of their first-year head coach.
Here’s how the whole situation played out on social media, with tweets from around the Denver sports scene weighing in…
Siemian rushing his throws. Mechanics lousy. Way off the mark so far. If this doesn't get better—and fast—well, you know… #broncos
— Les Shapiro (@LesShapiro) October 31, 2017
https://twitter.com/AllbrightNFL/status/925163122268213249
https://twitter.com/TJCarpenterShow/status/925163146909835266
13 has delivered 3 of the worst balls I’ve seen. Off to a terrible start.
— Mark Schlereth (@markschlereth) October 31, 2017
Marcus Peters, who forced a fumble and ran it back for a TD, has now intercepted Trevor Siemian too. Two turnovers for DEN in 9 minutes.
— Nicki Jhabvala (@NickiJhabvala) October 31, 2017
Does Vance Joseph want to get fired? WHY IS SIEMIAN STILL IN THE GAME?
— Will Petersen (@PetersenWill) October 31, 2017
Right now it seems obvious Siemian has lost confidence and isn't the same guy who won the job during camp. #BroncosCountry
— Eric Christensen (@cbseric) October 31, 2017
Did he just throw a go route to a rarely used TE vs one of the best corners in football ?!
— JoelDreessen (@JoelDreessen) October 31, 2017
Very nice drive by Siemian. Then the old red-zone issues. Field goal. Take the good – and the 3 points – where you can find em.
— Mark Kiszla (@markkiszla) October 31, 2017
https://twitter.com/AllbrightNFL/status/925170990946144256
Siemian has four completions and two interceptions with a QB rating of 6.9. #Denver7
— Troy Renck (@TroyRenck) October 31, 2017
Siemian had some awful pass protection on that roll-out INT, where he had the first down in the bag, right?
RIGHT?
— Ron (@RonnieKRadio) October 31, 2017
https://twitter.com/AllbrightNFL/status/925183022747586560
So, VJ said last night, he would stick with Siemian no matter what? Makes no sense. It's not ALL on your OL. A lot of it has been bad QB play. At what point do you say, "enough is enough?" #broncos
— Les Shapiro (@LesShapiro) October 31, 2017
https://twitter.com/DerekinDenver/status/925185088010166273
Vance realizes at some point this ALL falls on him right? Why not make a change to try to save your bacon? I don't get it.
— J D T (@BroadcastJesse) October 31, 2017
Keep in mind — we never see Fowler drop a TD pass if Siemian puts the ball on Janovich, who has never been more wide open.
— Sayre Bedinger (@SayreBedinger) October 31, 2017
Go back and look at that pass to Jano. That would be exhibit A in a court of law against Trevor.
— J D T (@BroadcastJesse) October 31, 2017
Siemian is staring down McKenzie, who really shouldn't be in the game anyways.
This coaching staff and offense looks completely lost.
— Ron (@RonnieKRadio) October 31, 2017
Jon Gruden: "Zone defense and he read the quarterback's eyes all the way."
This is a problem, coach.
— Doctor of Words (& tights & over/under guesses) (@docllv) October 31, 2017
I was surprised Broncos went for it on fourth down. Even more surprised McKenzie was the target. Booker was open in flat
— Troy Renck (@TroyRenck) October 31, 2017
Never throw across your body, Siemian. Weak armed Siemian. Stupid throw.
If he's not benched now, I mean, c'mon.
— Rich (midnight blue 🌠and sunshine yellow ☀️) (@RichKurtzman) October 31, 2017
That has to be the last throw Trevor Siemian throws as an #NFL starter — or Vance Joseph's last series as a head coach.
— Shawn Drotar (@sdrotar) October 31, 2017